Tragic motorbike death crash was ‘unavoidable’

The Bolton News: The scene of the accident The scene of the accident

NOTHING could have been done to prevent the death of a motorcyclist who crashed head-on into a van, a coroner has ruled.

Grandfather Michael Mangan, aged 72, from Turton, died from multiple traumatic injuries while overtaking on a bend along the A396 in Wheddon Cross, Somerset, on September 11.

Mr Mangan, a keen motorcyclist and senior observer for the Institute of Advanced Motorcyclists, was returning to Minehead with his son Insp Dave Mangan from a trip to Land’s End, an inquest in Taunton heard.

Gina McIntyre, who had been travelling in front of them, said: “Traffic was slow moving but the two motorcyclists behind me appeared to be in no hurry and I didn’t feel threatened by them at any point.

“The road is narrow and bending so there are very few opportunities to overtake.

“When the road straightened out a bit, the first motorcyclist overtook at about 40 to 45 miles per hour and managed to overtake all three cars in front.

“When the second motorcyclist overtook, he was travelling at a safe speed but he was over the white line for the other side of the road and I could see a yellow van in the other lane.

“There was smoke, bits flying everywhere, the motorcycle had gone into a hedge and the motorcyclist had gone flying into a field.”

Belgian doctor Anton Wildier, who had been travelling on the road, was the first to treat Mr Mangan.

Another witness Steven Jones said the van driver, Patrick Stuthers, had been travelling at a safe speed. Insp Mangan told the court how he sat in the field for a few hours afterwards.

He said: “I saw my father’s headlights raise up, meaning he was accelerating, I was concerned as I didn’t know if he had seen the van.

“I stopped at Wheddon Cross and a car pulled up beside me and asked had I been travelling with another motorcyclist as there had been an accident.

“When I found my father in the field, I saw the doctor carrying out CPR and I said he was gone.”

Recording a verdict of accidental death, West Somerset Coroner Michael Rose said: “I am satisfied that Mr Struthers could have done nothing to prevent the accident. This is a tragic case.”

Insp Mangan has since launched a safety campaign to help motorcyclists.

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:40pm Fri 23 May 14

Percy Thrower says...

Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic.
Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic. Percy Thrower
  • Score: 8

8:17pm Fri 23 May 14

bob the biker says...

Percy Thrower wrote:
Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic.
you seem to have a problem with motorcyclists and a bit of the green eyed monster best see a doctor
[quote][p][bold]Percy Thrower[/bold] wrote: Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic.[/p][/quote]you seem to have a problem with motorcyclists and a bit of the green eyed monster best see a doctor bob the biker
  • Score: -13

8:47pm Fri 23 May 14

Percy Thrower says...

I only have a problem with dangerous and selfish drivers. Why does that require me to see a doctor.
I only have a problem with dangerous and selfish drivers. Why does that require me to see a doctor. Percy Thrower
  • Score: 21

8:54pm Fri 23 May 14

bob the biker says...

Percy Thrower wrote:
I only have a problem with dangerous and selfish drivers. Why does that require me to see a doctor.
because you have a problem and will not admit it
[quote][p][bold]Percy Thrower[/bold] wrote: I only have a problem with dangerous and selfish drivers. Why does that require me to see a doctor.[/p][/quote]because you have a problem and will not admit it bob the biker
  • Score: -17

11:13pm Fri 23 May 14

Comment777 says...

Percy Thrower wrote:
Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic.
Why the negativity? This is a perfectly reasonable comment that empathises with the driver of the van, which I seem to remember was not referred to in any of the comments made when the accident was originally reported.
[quote][p][bold]Percy Thrower[/bold] wrote: Overtaking on a bend isn't an accidental death, it's reckless driving. I hope Mr Struthers realises that none of this was his fault, even if he was driving his van slower. These 2 selfish motorcyclists obviously thought they had priority to be at the front of the rest of the queuing traffic.[/p][/quote]Why the negativity? This is a perfectly reasonable comment that empathises with the driver of the van, which I seem to remember was not referred to in any of the comments made when the accident was originally reported. Comment777
  • Score: 16

11:17pm Fri 23 May 14

Comment777 says...

“When the second motorcyclist overtook, he was travelling at a safe speed but he was over the white line for the other side of the road and I could see a yellow van in the other lane.

His speed was not that safe. Person's opinions about what is a safe speed seem to be based on indicated speed limits. If the motorcyclist involved in the collision had doubled his speed he may have passed the cars and enjoyed the rest of his ride home.
“When the second motorcyclist overtook, he was travelling at a safe speed but he was over the white line for the other side of the road and I could see a yellow van in the other lane. His speed was not that safe. Person's opinions about what is a safe speed seem to be based on indicated speed limits. If the motorcyclist involved in the collision had doubled his speed he may have passed the cars and enjoyed the rest of his ride home. Comment777
  • Score: 4

12:42pm Sat 24 May 14

boltonnut says...

Unavoidable is once again a bad choice of wording by B.N.Unavoidable means it was predestined to happen.A certain amount of error was involved in this unfortunate accident,error can be avoided.
Unavoidable is once again a bad choice of wording by B.N.Unavoidable means it was predestined to happen.A certain amount of error was involved in this unfortunate accident,error can be avoided. boltonnut
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree