Seconds in taxi rank means a £70 fine
9:50am Sunday 27th January 2013 in News
A MOTORING expert has accused Bolton Council of running a “money-making scheme" by fining drivers who stop in taxi ranks for only a few seconds.
Hugh German, a member of Bolton’s Institute of Advanced Motorists, was shocked to receive a £70 fine after stopping in the taxi rank in Knowsley Street for 14 seconds to drop off his wife on December 13, last year.
Another driver, Rod Pilling, was also angry to discover he had been fined in the same spot despite CCTV footage revealing he had been stopped on the taxi rank for just 12 seconds on December 10 last year.
The fine is £70, reduced by half if paid promptly.
Mr German said: “I reluctantly paid the £35 demanded.
I suspect that many others are unjustly charged and take the same option.
“I also believe that this type of action by Bolton Council is nothing more than a money-making scheme and that it contributes nothing to improving road safety or traffic flow. Bolton town centre is notorious for its pedantic enforcement of parking restrictions. No wonder shops are closing and would-be visitors and even many Bolton citizens go elsewhere for their shopping.”
He said appealing the fine would have involved further cost and the inconvenience of going to a traffic penalty tribunal.
Janice Pilling, aged 62, who is retired, from Westhoughton, said pictures of her husband’s Hyundai car in the taxi rank, sent by Bolton Council, show the car leaving after 10 seconds.
She said: “My husband dropped me off while I got my mum, who has dementia, some money out for Christmas from the Halifax.
“I think it’s probably a way for the council to get extra money because they have to save money again.”
A council spokesman said: “Both of these individuals have accepted they had stopped there illegally and have paid their fines.
“We acknowledge that these drivers felt their fines were unfair because they were only there for a short period of time.
“However, the taxi rank is clearly signposted and stopping in the rank even for a few seconds could prevent a taxi from parking and picking up a fare.
“If a motorist does feel they have been fined unfairly they can challenge their fine.”
Comments are closed on this article.

Comments (82)
9:07am Sat 26 Jan 13
georgethebrave says...
9:34am Sat 26 Jan 13
steveG says...
tives of the people.
What on earth is going on when these same people,there to represent our interests,blatantly preside over a system designed to make as much money as possible,with blatant disregard for their constituents?
Councillors need to reflect and ask themselves is this the reason they stood for public office.
10:12am Sat 26 Jan 13
EllenSpeaks says...
10:13am Sat 26 Jan 13
John Edwards says...
10:14am Sat 26 Jan 13
EllenSpeaks says...
11:09am Sat 26 Jan 13
Tel30 says...
because I wont go near the place.
11:10am Sat 26 Jan 13
Tel30 says...
because I won't go near the place.
11:20am Sat 26 Jan 13
georgethebrave says...
12:08pm Sat 26 Jan 13
berushka says...
12:08pm Sat 26 Jan 13
berushka says...
12:47pm Sat 26 Jan 13
boltonnut says...
1:46pm Sat 26 Jan 13
pecky2k says...
2:23pm Sat 26 Jan 13
tony000 says...
5:41pm Sat 26 Jan 13
bwfc0210 says...
7:24pm Sat 26 Jan 13
KEEPINLANE says...
I parked at the car-park on the 'upmarket' shopping mall (God knows the exact name) and found there was no way I could bring our dog down to street level without offending the 'jobs worth' mall security/mall manager.
FOR GOD'S SAKE, I JUST WANTED TO GET OUT OF THE DUMP!!!!!
8:21pm Sat 26 Jan 13
dougie kay says...
9:29pm Sat 26 Jan 13
Leftythelion says...
2:09am Sun 27 Jan 13
chris25 says...
7:32am Sun 27 Jan 13
jjb2000 says...
We've only got a still image to go off that shows the car but obviously no movement, and while we can't really afford the ridiculously inflated fine cost, we certainly can't afford to take on BMBC'd legal team, and in my opinion it's this indirect intimidation that means the little people just pay rather than fight.
It's about time the proceeds of this stealth tax were used to sort out Boltons abysmal road surfaces!
BMBC? Meh!
10:47am Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
There are more than enough places to legally park your car, so dont complain if you chose to ignore the regulations and get caught.
10:49am Sun 27 Jan 13
atlas123 says...
I've never had a parking ticket either.... I don't stop where I shouldn't simples
10:53am Sun 27 Jan 13
OutoftheEU says...
The town hall "modernisation" was the beginning of the end; and it has continued ever since. The only way to regenerate the town centre is to give free rates for 12 months for existing and new start up businesses and free parking - only that would compromise any agreements they have with private companies.
Parking fines are just madness in this economic climate. Madness for the people that receive them, madness from the business lost out on as a result and madness for promoting a welcoming town centre.
We go to Bury now.
10:55am Sun 27 Jan 13
Jenon Travel Bolton says...
10:58am Sun 27 Jan 13
Jenon Travel Bolton says...
12:28pm Sun 27 Jan 13
genesis22 says...
12:38pm Sun 27 Jan 13
cosmicma says...
there's nothing left to make it worth while visiting
12:46pm Sun 27 Jan 13
pstuart says...
When I got ambushed here last year I was so annoyed that in my protestations to them I included the fact that just less than 1000 people were fined here in 2010 to 2011 (obtained under the Freedom of Information Act).
So its more like thousands, not hundreds!
Cheeky robbing b.ggers.
12:56pm Sun 27 Jan 13
questionairre says...
easy
5:11pm Sun 27 Jan 13
zoomzam says...
6:02pm Sun 27 Jan 13
JustBecause says...
6:37pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ownerdriver says...
6:42pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ownerdriver says...
7:27pm Sun 27 Jan 13
BWFC71 says...
BOLTON COUNCIL DO NOT SET THE RATES - CENTRAL GOVERNMENT DO!!!
Bolton Council only collect the rates on behalf of the Government!!!
7:36pm Sun 27 Jan 13
chris25 says...
7:58pm Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
You broke the law.
You were caught breaking the law.
Pay the bloomin fine and dont do it again.
If someone broke into your house would you be happy for them to get off scott free if they claimed that they were only in your house for 15 seconds ?
No you bl00dy well wouldnt.
Dont break the law and you wont get a fine.
Its not flamin rocket science is it ???
I park up in an official car park and walk (no fine)
You decide that the rules dont apply to you and stop where you want (a fine.)
Basically thats it in a nutshell.
Use the bl00dy car parks.
7:59pm Sun 27 Jan 13
Rememberscarborough says...
8:02pm Sun 27 Jan 13
bouncyball55 says...
8:11pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
8:17pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
i'm sure you never broke a single law ever ,, not even an infringement,,,Wow
what a hero
8:18pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
8:32pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
i bet mrs Davrok loves and feels so Safe on her nights out in bolton...
8:56pm Sun 27 Jan 13
BWFC71 says...
9:03pm Sun 27 Jan 13
mc1986 says...
9:11pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
9:11pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
9:17pm Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
Yes if I was dropping my wife off I would pull up somewhere near the venue and not in a car park. (Common sense)
BUT !!!!!!!!!!
If I decided to pull up somewhere that I wasnt allowed to stop then I would be taking a chance, and in taking that chance I would have to abide by the law, and pay the fine if caught.
My point is that you know you are doing wrong, so cant argue if you are caught out..
Mrs davroduk wouldnt ever go on a night out in Bolton cos its too dangerous, but thats a side issue.
You and others on here seem to be saying that its ok to break the law if it suits your purpose.
I am saying that if that is your belief then you cannot argue when caught and fined.
As happens on every story thread on here some brainless moron makes a personall comment against another poster, and congratulations on this occasion its you !!!!!
9:28pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
Lighten up ,, chill out and make sure you dont drive over 30 mph Davorok... the smart car may be watching LOL
we are not saying its ok to break the law,, its your pathetic post that butter would not melt...and i can comment on what ever i want,,,especially yours .. as it has to be the worst ever
9:31pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
Yes if I was dropping my wife off I would pull up somewhere near the venue and not in a car park. (Common sense)
LAW BREAKER !!!! so now you admit it ....hahahhahahaha
9:39pm Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
I point you back to my previous post about a moron making it personall and rest my case,
9:44pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
on,,,,, some people actually care who;s in the car and there safety...no matter the fine... You are the moron,,
9:46pm Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
9:47pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
davroduk1 wrote:
It seems to be a lot of people on here complaining that they only broke the law for a short period of time, and therfore it shouldnt count.
You broke the law.
You were caught breaking the law.
Pay the bloomin fine and dont do it again.
If someone broke into your house would you be happy for them to get off scott free if they claimed that they were only in your house for 15 seconds ?
No you bl00dy well wouldnt.
Dont break the law and you wont get a fine.
Its not flamin rocket science is it ???
I park up in an official car park and walk (no fine)
You decide that the rules dont apply to you and stop where you want (a fine.)
Basically thats it in a nutshell.
Use the bl00dy car parks.
9:48pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
9:55pm Sun 27 Jan 13
davroduk1 says...
You have just taken it upon yourself to decide that I am some silly person who doesnt deserve to post on a website.
A bit crazy dont you think ??
10:08pm Sun 27 Jan 13
ohboltonweloveu says...
everyones opinion differs
11:09pm Sun 27 Jan 13
MarkAllRead says...
5:26am Mon 28 Jan 13
ARBEE says...
you MORONS !!
5:26am Mon 28 Jan 13
ARBEE says...
you MORONS !!
7:27am Mon 28 Jan 13
BigDave1985 says...
12:04pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Badvock says...
12:10pm Mon 28 Jan 13
degsey says...
12:25pm Mon 28 Jan 13
brian jones says...
12:47pm Mon 28 Jan 13
cliff4treasurer says...
1:05pm Mon 28 Jan 13
berushka says...
1:29pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Harry-Joe says...
Why people think its ok to stop in bus lanes, park on bends, park on double yellows or stop in taxi bays is a mystery.
YOUR NOT ALLOWED TO, SO DONT DO IT OR ELSE YOU WILL GET A FINE!!
Its cant really be any simpler and i am not exactly sure why this is a news story. Whats the next Story...
'Punching someone will result in a charge for assault'
Everyone always says oh its money making by the council. Well your the ones letting it happen. Dont give them the chance to make money out of you.
2:13pm Mon 28 Jan 13
brian jones says...
3:59pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Harry-Joe says...
4:33pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Tel30 says...
4:55pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Don Kiddick says...
I'm still feeling fine,
I've not far to go,
And this bitter's sublime,
It doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for others, not me.
I'll park in disabled,
I'll park where I please,
I'll park on the hatchings,
and f**k the signs' pleas.
It doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for others, not me.
I'll chat on my phone,
As i drive through the rain,
The killing of innocents,
My claim to fame.
It doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for others, not me.
I'll travel at fifty,
To get to my post,
The sign may say thirty,
But I an better than most.
It doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for others, not me.
You looked at me wrong,
So you're goin' down,
You'll pay with your life,
For that harmless frown.
It doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for others, not me.
I'll snuff out your life,
And the life of your infants,
You mean nothing to me,
'Cos I'm so important.
So it doesn't apply, you see?
The law's for other's, NOT ME.
5:06pm Mon 28 Jan 13
littlebugs says...
5:09pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Citizen Cane says...
Do a freedom of information request on Bolton council on the recovery rate of fines - it'll be pretty poor. Only decent folk pay.
5:11pm Mon 28 Jan 13
brian jones says...
5:13pm Mon 28 Jan 13
brian jones says...
5:26pm Mon 28 Jan 13
marco999 says...
5:59pm Mon 28 Jan 13
pstuart says...
The point that most people are trying to make is that the enforcrment officers only gather round the easy feeding places, some of which the signage is either misleading or illegal (Queen St. - permit only?)
Lurking around the Court car parks is just disgraceful, they know that people can be delayed in the Town Hall and the Courts, its not as though there are long lines of traffic waiting to park - people only go into Bolton Town centre if they have to - the Council have seen to that.
9:49pm Mon 28 Jan 13
colournature says...
10:22pm Mon 28 Jan 13
Don Kiddick says...
10:38am Tue 29 Jan 13
KeepPosting ! says...
11:34am Tue 29 Jan 13
yonmons says...
12:58pm Tue 29 Jan 13
DaveLister says...
We never bother going into Bolton any more we go to Trafford Centre, there is lots of free parking, lots of shops, and its no more expensive than Bolton.
Councilor Morris has done a great job of killing off Bolton. I can only hope he doesnt get re-elected, but I hold out no hope the people of his ward will vote for anything with a red rosette
12:06am Fri 1 Feb 13
iseethings says...
12:15am Fri 1 Feb 13
iseethings says...