Hospital chairman gets backing of watchdog

HEALTH watchdog Monitor said it is “supportive” of Bolton NHS Foundation Trust’s interim chairman David Wakefield in the wake of the mortality rate investigation.

Monitor, who appointed Mr Wakefield as chairman in August, said it is “encouraged” by his work to strengthen the board.

It comes as the trust faces a leadership void. It currently has no chief executive, an acting deputy chief executive and an acting medical director.

On Wednesday, Mr Wakefield told The Bolton News he would be “bringing in additional resources” and would announce changes to board members yesterday.

But he has yet to make an announcement.

The acting chief executive, Dr Jackie Bene, “stepped aside” earlier this week after it was announced an investigation by healthcare information expert Dr Foster into the way patients were “coded” at the hospital had been launched.

The trust recorded 800 cases of septicaemia between March, 2011, and April, 2012 — a similar-sized trust would have 200.

The investigation’s results will be released next Wednesday.

If patients have been coded incorrectly as having died from septicaemia, which is not included in mortality figures, it could affect Bolton’s death records.

Bolton’s death figures dramatically improved in 2011 after six consecutive years when they had been among the worst in the country.

It could also affect finances, as cases of septicaemia receive more money than other infections.

The trust is being monitored by Monitor for being in “significant breach”, in “red risk” and at the highest risk level of one for poor governance, failing to achieve healthcare targets and financial failings.

It is currently more than £14.5 million in debt and is losing about £1.5 million each month. Monitor intervened in August after it was discovered £3.8 million was “unaccounted” for at the Trust.

Since August, the governing board has faced a number of changes.

Mr Wakefield replaced the chairman, Cllr Cliff Morris, leader of Bolton Council, who left three months early after eight years in the post.

The director of finance, Gary Raphael, left by “mutual agreement” in September and has been replaced by three interim directors.

Chief executive Lesley Doherty took early retirement at Christmas and the director of assurance and engagement, Beverley Andrew, followed in January. Neither have been replaced. There have also been two interim chief operations officers and a temporary turnaround director was appointed in September.

Orthopaedic surgeon Steve Hodgson was appointed acting medical director in January after Dr Jackie Bene was appointed acting chief executive.

The trust held interviews in January for a permanent chief executive but were unable to find anyone suitable.

A Monitor spokesman said: “Monitor is supportive of the trust’s interim chairman and his timely action in responding to the concerns raised by this issue.

“Last August, Monitor intervened to appoint the interim chairman after an independent review into board governance raised concerns in relation to the previous leadership at the trust, which the interim chair has been working to address.

“We are also encouraged by the interim chair’s steps to strengthen the trust’s management at executive level in both the short and medium term.

“Monitor will work with the trust to ensure recommendations from the independent review are implemented in full.”

Cllr Andy Morgan, who sits on the Health, Overview and Scrutiny Committee, said the hospital needed a strong leadership.

“Somebody needs to get to grips with the situation and get a chief executive at the trust. Monitor should be here making sure this is sorted as soon as possible,” he added.

Comments(12)

boltonchap says...
9:35am Fri 1 Mar 13

When are we going to be told about what happened to the missing millions? They've been looking into this for months now.

BWFC71 says...
9:58am Fri 1 Mar 13

That is the first bit of good news in a long while.

But as above we need answers to what has been happening from where are the millions, under Cliff Morris direction to these mortality rates!!! It seems to me that the hierarchy definitely took their eye off the ball - why???

duffbikes says...
10:35am Fri 1 Mar 13

And what of the patients in all this, the lesson is they have become customers, not patients in a world where the NHS has become partners with the financiers of 'rip off Britain'.

tinman2 says...
11:17am Fri 1 Mar 13

BWFC 71.This Trust seems to have been obsessed with initiatives like the BICS team a legacy of the CEO prior to Ms Doherty, perhaps if the trust under her ill fated regime could have focused on patient care and proper financial management this hospital wouldn't be at the bottom of the league in so many of its activities eg whether doctors and nurses would be happy the see their relatives treated at this hospital.

Rememberscarborough says...
12:11pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Interesting that the BBC last night chose to finish off a piece on Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust with library pictures of Bolton Hospitals Foundation Trust. When even a notoriously cautious organisation like the BBC is linking the two together then the future for BHFT looks very bleak. If Mid Staffs has been put in to administration because it is no longer viable both medically or financially then it's obvious that BHFT is going to go exactly the same way.

If the debacle at Mid Staffordshire has resulted in a public inquiry then we must have exactly the same at Bolton because those responsible, both past and present, must be held responsible and action must be taken to ensure they do not put the Bolton public at risk both on safety and financial levels

Love Bolton says...
1:15pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Is it more risky to retain a hospital in this condition or to let it be closed?
Seems to me the continuous 'uncovering' of new issues has the potential to have a motivation behind it of closure.

I have used services at the hospital
- maternity services which were just appalling - I gulped when it was given super maternity status, as in comparison to my previous experience, it was beyond exceedingly poor
- other services, including emergency, routine, specialist - which were of the highest quality I have ever seen, seamless from doctor through to final service, just outstanding

There are definitely somethings that need to be changed, I do not understand whether someone would have the drive to keep the hospital open and improve services when they are a temporary chair, with a temporary set of leadership.

Also, does anyone else find it strange that the Chairman seems to think he can be Chair and CEO? There is a really good reason why these roles are legislatively kept separate. He needs to focus on becoming an outstanding Chairman and appoint a permanent CEO who has the drive to make the right impact and skills to deliver.

Chris Custodiet says...
2:15pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Rememberscarborough wrote:
Interesting that the BBC last night chose to finish off a piece on Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust with library pictures of Bolton Hospitals Foundation Trust. When even a notoriously cautious organisation like the BBC is linking the two together then the future for BHFT looks very bleak. If Mid Staffs has been put in to administration because it is no longer viable both medically or financially then it's obvious that BHFT is going to go exactly the same way.

If the debacle at Mid Staffordshire has resulted in a public inquiry then we must have exactly the same at Bolton because those responsible, both past and present, must be held responsible and action must be taken to ensure they do not put the Bolton public at risk both on safety and financial levels
Remind me. Who has been held responsible for Mid-Staffs? The NHS is institutionally inhumane and untrustworthy and will remain so until there are enough politicians worthy of your vote. At present 18 MPS have signed the EDM for the removal of the responsible individual, Sir David Nicholson. None of them are from Bolton.

macauley says...
2:55pm Fri 1 Mar 13

last out turn the lights out please.

azincourt says...
8:13pm Fri 1 Mar 13

people waiting to go in this place for treatment must be terrified at the prospect.these stumps should be prosecuted not allowed to "step aside"

azincourt says...
8:23pm Fri 1 Mar 13

cliff morris left three months early no suprise there .isnt that what rats do on a leaky ship

Logica says...
11:22pm Fri 1 Mar 13

There are clearly lots of very serious issues at Royal Bolton one of which is financial. Where is the previous Finance Director and what has happened to the senior finance manager responsible for income?

Chris Custodiet says...
11:47pm Fri 1 Mar 13

20 MPs now signed the EDM for Nicholson's removal. None from Bolton. Ask them why not.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree