Why Bolton Wanderers can't let their promotion hopes drift

5
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

NINE games without defeat and third in the table… But why so glum?

In 65 days, Wanderers will round-off the regular season at the Toughsheet Stadium against Luton Town, but one wonders what the prevailing emotion will be on the day?

Steven Schumacher’s side go to Exeter this weekend hoping to spark an unlikely note of hope inside a fanbase which is slowly resigning itself for another tilt at the play-offs.

More than a quarter of the season still remains and ordinarily that would represent ample time to mount a charge. Yet with a 10-point gap to Lincoln and 11 to Cardiff – who both have a game in hand – common consensus suggests otherwise.

Schumacher has recently found himself leading a press conference pep rally, urging the club’s supporters – and by extension his own squad – not to surrender, and that the club must be ready to capitalise on any slip from the teams above.

Logically, he is entirely correct. There are still 36 points available to Wanderers, and however unlikely it may seem after three consecutive draws, it is still possible for them to mount a significant winning run.

Steven Schumacher is urging fans to stay positive in the final stretch of the season (Image: CameraSport - David Horton)

Cardiff City's Dylan Lawlor in action at the Toughsheet with Bolton's Mason Burstow (Image: CameraSport - Shaun Brooks)

If the automatic spots prove beyond them, a third-placed finish may also prove an advantage to Bolton if they are to enter into the play-offs. Playing at home in the second leg statistically offers a better route to the final, albeit a slim one, with recent studies showing a 53 to 55 per cent probability over the major competitions in European football.

Momentum is also a factor. When Bruce Rioch took Bolton into the play-offs in 1994/95, only one automatic promotion spot was available because the Premier League was being trimmed down. As such, once Middlesbrough claimed the crown, some around the top six suddenly lost focus.

Wanderers took six points from the last 21 available and Tranmere Rovers managed just two from 15. Reading moved into second spot after winning their last four and Wolves held on to fourth, drawing their last two games to confirm what at the time was their highest finish in more than a decade.

That may have taken the edge off Bolton’s performance in the first leg at Molineux, where Jason McAteer’s goal game them a fighting chance but Graham Taylor’s side went to Burnden as favourites after a 2-1 win. Mercifully, Rioch’s side rediscovered their bite, and the rest is history.

Wanderers have lost just six times this season – as many as Cardiff – but the 13 drawn games are where they have lost ground. And the club record 17 draws, achieved under Phil Neal in the 1991/92 season, could well be under threat if Schumacher fails to keep the wind in the Whites’ sails going down the final strait.

Current form is not a huge concern. The fact that Wanderers are currently looking up longingly at Lincoln and Cardiff is largely down to their form over Christmas.

At the start of December, scrappy wins against Mansfield Town and this weekend’s opponents Exeter brought them on to Lincoln’s shoulder but the run of five points from a possible 18 over the festive period has proved more damaging than anyone could have imagined at the time.

Lincoln City have been frighteningly consistent at the top end of League One (Image: CameraSport - Lee Parker)

Points totals for Cardiff City, Lincoln City and Bolton Wanderers through the 2025/26 season so far (Image: NQ)

Lincoln’s consistency has been frightening. Michael Skubala’s side have won 11 and drawn four of their last 15 games. Cardiff, though soundly beaten at Plymouth last weekend, have also added a massive 31 points during that time.

Though the Welsh side went into the season as one of the promotion favourites, few viewed Lincoln as anything other than play-off dark horses.

For the Imps to implode at this point would take something even more spectacular than occurred in 2021, when after leading the table on Valentine’s Day they took just 22 points from their final 20 games and dropped to fifth, with Hull City and Peterborough United claiming the automatic spots.

Lincoln did recover to beat Sunderland over two legs in the play-offs but lost to Blackpool in the final at Wembley and until now have not managed to catch fire in quite the same way again.

From boardroom to boot room, Bolton have made little secret of their own promotion ambitions from the start. After coming in midway through last season and getting a good look at the squad he inherited from Ian Evatt, Schumacher has undertaken quite the rebuild, bringing in a total of 21 players across the summer and winter transfer windows.

Paradoxically, the team he selected to face Evatt’s Blackpool on Saturday contained six players signed by his predecessor – Chris Forino, Jordi Osei-Tutu, George Johnston, Josh Sheehan, Kyle Dempsey and Eoin Toal.

Whether this can truly be argued to be “Schumacher’s team” or not, the Bolton boss knows by now what expectation he carries on his shoulders. And with the news that Sheffield Wednesday have already added their name to next season’s League One list, and the knowledge that big hitters like West Brom, Leicester City and Blackburn Rovers are entangled in the Championship relegation battle, pressure to go up this term is perhaps even greater.

Many Wanderers fans are already resigned to competing for the play-offs with 12 games to go (Image: CameraSport - Alex Dodd)

It has been pondered for some time whether this is Bolton’s ‘best chance’ to escape League One automatically in the five years they have been at this level, which explains some of the irritability. There are no noticeably massive budgets with which to contend but this has turned out to be a campaign where the lack of a stand-out team in League One has made consistency an even more precious commodity.

Wanderers’ current ability to dig deep and avoid defeat is not an unhelpful characteristic if the play-offs are beckoning once again. But if they are aiming for something more spectacular, one may suggest that Lincoln or Cardiff must start to wobble very soon.

The fact that 11,000-plus have already signed up for season tickets for 2026/27 suggests that all is not terrible.

And if one thing is true in football, it is that one result can change a lot. And should that be the case this weekend at Exeter, who knows? Maybe we’ll all cheer up again?

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos