GCSE U-turn is step in right direction

HEADTEACHERS have welcomed Michael Gove’s dramatic U-turn over plans to axe GCSEs.

The education secretary’s flagship plan to ditch the exams and replace them with new English Baccalaureate Certificates (EBCs) in core academic subjects are said to have been abandoned following widespread opposition and pressure from the Conservatives’ coalition partners, the Liberal Democrats.

Headteachers des-cribed it is a “step in the right direction” and called for confidence to be restored in the exams by addressing problems that exist in the system.

Chairman of Bolton Secondary Headteachers John Porteous said: “Some commentators are talking about a climbdown, but in reality this is at least one step in the right direction.

“The EBacc was never a sensible solution for the 21st century world our students will move into.

“The important thing now is to think through properly how GCSE exams are to be refined and to rebuild confidence in the system.

“Our young people need to know where they stand as they make option choices and plan their futures.

“Some consistency and stability from government and examination authorities will be helpful.”

Head of Bolton School Boys’ Division, Philip Britton, said he was pleased that the EBC would not be the “way forward”.

But he added: “We should not forget that staying as things are with GCSE is not a way forward either.

“There are problems with GCSE which need to be addressed, the most acute of which are their ability to stretch the able and, more generally, the quality and reliability of the assessment.

“Nothing will get better with qualifications until the government properly add- resses the fact that exam results year-on-year vary widely when the ability of the pupils does not.”

Mr Gove has set out alternative proposals to reform GCSEs instead of introducing EBC in core subjects.

New GCSEs in English, maths, science, history and geography will be ready for teaching in 2015.

They will still be “universal qualifications”, taken by the vast majority of pupils.

The qualifications will no longer be modular and will rely on end-of-course exams, which will test extended writing in subjects such as English, with less structured questions.

Internal assessment and the use of exam aids will also be kept to a minimum.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:13am Sat 9 Feb 13

PDY says...

The answer is very simple. We should go back to the same syllabus as the "old" GCE O level. Include subjects like ITC if you want to make it inclusive of the "modern world" but keep the same syllabus. The Teaching unions in this country are left wing and "anti-failure". The GCSE papers are far too easy and the pass levels are difficult for employers to interpret. The old GCE O levels gave a very definite standard of pass or, dare I say it, failure and were of a higher academic level. It is impossible to include all levels of academic ability in one single system of testing. Some kids simply do not have academic ability but excel in other areas. The Government, Teaching Unions and Employers Associations should agree on a parallel education system that allows kids for whom an apprentice based style of education would be best suited. Lets give the less academic kids a chance to be painters, electricians, plasterers and stop using overseas labour to fill this gap. There are loads of retired or redundan skilled tradesmen who would jump at the chance to teach hands on stuff. The kids could study basic English and Maths as well.
The answer is very simple. We should go back to the same syllabus as the "old" GCE O level. Include subjects like ITC if you want to make it inclusive of the "modern world" but keep the same syllabus. The Teaching unions in this country are left wing and "anti-failure". The GCSE papers are far too easy and the pass levels are difficult for employers to interpret. The old GCE O levels gave a very definite standard of pass or, dare I say it, failure and were of a higher academic level. It is impossible to include all levels of academic ability in one single system of testing. Some kids simply do not have academic ability but excel in other areas. The Government, Teaching Unions and Employers Associations should agree on a parallel education system that allows kids for whom an apprentice based style of education would be best suited. Lets give the less academic kids a chance to be painters, electricians, plasterers and stop using overseas labour to fill this gap. There are loads of retired or redundan skilled tradesmen who would jump at the chance to teach hands on stuff. The kids could study basic English and Maths as well. PDY

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree