THE best and worst GP practices in Bolton have been revealed after the release of a patients’ survey.

The annual report asked surgery users about their experiences of their local practices and asks them about service access, making an appointment, waiting times, care during appointments, opening hours and out of hours service.

The Pikes Lane Centre in Deane Road came top of the table with 98 per cent of patients describing the practice as good, with Halliwell Surgery in second but also on 98 per cent.

Deane Clinic, in Horsfield Street, was bottom of the pile with 61 per cent.

Overall, GP surgery’s in the Bolton Clinical Commissioning Group area received a satisfaction rating of 87 per cent, above the national average of 85 per cent.

Other surgeries in the top five included Halliwell, Great Lever Health Centre, Egerton and Dunscar Health Centre and Mandalay Medical Centre.

And as well as Deane Clinic, the bottom five was made up of the two surgeries from Little Lever Health Centre, Shanti Medical Centre and Deane Medical Centre, but all polled above 60 per cent.

On a CCG-wide basis, the access of getting through to surgeries on the phone stood at 7 per cent, seven points above the national average of 68 per cent.

In this category, Mandalay Medical Centre in Astley Bridge was top with 98 per cent while Bolton General Practice was bottom with 44 per cent.

Great Lever Health Centre had the most helpful receptionists according to the report and Deane Clinic was bottom but with 71 per cent of people surveyed saying their staff were helpful.

Around 82 per cent of Bolton patients were happy with the convenience of their appointment and 76 per cent were pleased with the process of making an appointment to see their GP, against a national average of 73 per cent.

And 93 per cent of patients in Bolton said they were happy with the appointment they had.

But waiting times were a sore point with 31 per cent of patients, who believed the wait was too long.

Mandalay Medical Centre faired the best, with 85 per cent who would not be waiting too long to be seen, compared to Deane Clinic patients, 80 per cent of who waited too long.

In terms of the GP practices’ online services, Bolton matched the national average of 46 per cent of people who did not know.

Furthermore, 85 per cent of patients surveyed in Bolton said they did not use any online services offered by the surgeries, compared to a national figure of 82 per cent.

The survey was sent to 2.15million adult patients in the UK and 808,332 responded.

Overall patient satisfaction results (as reported by Ipsos MORI)

Pikes Lane 2 – 98%

Halliwell Surgery 2 – 98%

Great Lever Health Centre 1 – 97%

Egerton/Dunscar Health Centre – 97%

Mandalay Health Centre – 96%

Olive Family Practice – 95%

Burnside Surgery – 95%

Kearsley Medical Centre – 95%

Cornerstone Surgery – 94%

Halliwell Surgery 1 – 94%

Kirby-Crompton Health Centre – 94%

Dalefield Surgery – 94%

Crompton Health Centre – 93%

Tonge Fold Health Centre – 93%

Unsworth Group Practice – 92%

Great Lever Practice – 91%

Edgworth Medical Centre – 91%

Stable Fold Surgery – 91%

Spring View Medical Centre – 89%

Farnworth Health Centre 1 – 89%

Swan Lane Medical Centre – 89%

Bradford Street Surgery - 88%

Lever Chambers 1 – 88%

The Dunstain Partnership – 88%

Farnworth Health Centre 2 – 87%

Wyresdale Road Surger – 87%

Orient House Medical Centre – 87%

Dr Malhotra and Partners – 87%

Pikes Lane 1 – 87%

Bolton Community Practice – 86%

Bolton Medical Centre – 86%

Lever Chambers 2 – 86%

Halliwell Surgery 3 – 85%

3D Medical Centre – 84%

Heaton Medical Centre – 83%

The Alastair Ross Medical Practice – 83%

Harwood Medical Centre – 83%

Bolton General Practice – 82%

Kildonan House – 82%

Spring House Surgery – 81%

Stonehill Medical Centre – 81%

Al Fal Medical Group – 80%

St Helens Road Practice – 79%

Charlotte Street Surgery – 78%

Beehive Surgery – 77%

Little Lever Health Centre 2 – 75%

Deane Medical Centre – 74%

Shanti Medical Centre – 73%

Little Lever Health Centre 1 – 71%

Deane Clinic 1 – 61%

Community answers

What do you think of your GP surgery?

"What do you think of the results of the patients’ survey of GP practices? How does yours fare and do you agree? Let us know. "

We asked for your responses - this is what you sent.

From Patricia Allen

What is your response?Dunstan Partnership would be at the top of my list, good doctors, (though I shall miss Dr Lynch, who has retired) pleasant and helpful nursing and reception staff. Appointments are easy to make as well and waiting times not bad.

From Community contributor

What is your response?The Beehive Doctors' Surgery on Crescent Road in Bolton. Doctors, nurses and receptionists are good here.

From Joseph Harrington

What is your response?Appointments are far too difficult to make, and if you are lucky enough to get an appointment you can sometimes be kept waiting up to half an hour beyond your given time, even though you are the first patient of that session. Also when trying to make a double appointment, as supposedly you should be able to, the receptionist tells you that you can't, yet you are told one appointment is for one ailment.

From Janak Salvi

What is your response?Beehive Surgery is absolutely terrible. Getting an appointment is non existent with advice to contact the out of hours service. I would like to know what their definition of 'SERVICE' is.

From Community contributor

What is your response?Generally very pleased with Spring View Little Lever. Great for same day appointments when needed and I even got an appointment 10.30am Christmas Day when I rang up that morning. Only comment might be not being contacted for regular MOTs medical, BP checks etc, like we used to. The nurses these days just don't seem to monitor weight, BPs and lifestyle like they used to.

From Rashida Patel

What is your response?Can't book appointment online at my own surgery, long wait on phone, when you finaly get through non available.

From Community contributor

What is your response?Due to waiting times for an appointment, most of the time I do not make an appointment and resolve issues with over the counter products.

From Darren Draj

What is your response?I've not got any negatives about my surgery (Crompton Health Centre), pleasant staff, great doctors and nurses. 100% from me.

From James Lord

What is your response?Farnworth Health Centre. I have been a patient since it opened and the service as been excellent. Cannot fault it.

From Ann Szmagala

What is your response?Appointment wait time ridiculous at Heaton Medical Centre.